Lemon Posset Recipe: The Creamiest, Easiest Citrus Dessert You’ll Ever Make

The lemon posset recipe is the perfect go-to for anyone craving a decadent, tangy, and refreshingly light dessert with minimal effort. With just three simple ingredients—heavy cream, sugar, and lemon juice—this no-bake British treat sets into a silky, spoonable dream that’s as elegant as it is easy to prepare. Whether you’re planning a dinner party or want to enjoy a citrusy delight at home, lemon posset delivers big flavor with little fuss.

In this ultimate guide, we’ll walk you through everything from the dessert’s origin and essential ingredients to expert-level tips and exciting variations. We’ll also answer common questions, show how it compares to crème brûlée and lemon curd, and even share how to recreate Mary Berry’s famous twist on the recipe.

Ingredients Needed for the Best Lemon Posset Recipe

Key Ingredients: Cream, Sugar, and Lemons Explained

At the heart of any great lemon posset recipe are just three essential ingredients: heavy cream, granulated sugar, and fresh lemon juice. The magic lies in how these basic items interact to create a velvety-smooth dessert. Let’s break down each component:

• Heavy Cream: Always choose full-fat heavy cream with at least 36% milk fat. The richness of the cream ensures your lemon posset sets beautifully without any help from gelatin or eggs.
• Granulated Sugar: Standard white sugar balances the tartness of the lemon and adds structure. Fine sugar melts quickly, making it ideal for smoother results.
• Lemon Juice: Fresh lemon juice is non-negotiable. Bottled varieties often lack the punch and acidity needed for the lemon posset recipe to thicken properly. Opt for bright, juicy lemons and strain the juice to remove any pulp or seeds.

This trio forms the foundation of the dessert, and although it might seem simple, the quality of each ingredient has a dramatic impact on the outcome.

Don’t miss our lemon-inspired pasta salad recipe: Check out this lemon-chicken-pasta-salad

Why Quality Matters: Choosing the Right Lemons and Cream

The success of your lemon posset recipe hinges on the acidity of your lemons and the fat content of your cream. Meyer lemons, with their floral notes, make a milder posset, while standard Lisbon or Eureka lemons give that classic, tangy punch. For cream, avoid anything labeled “light” or “half-and-half” as they won’t set properly.

Remember, even the best lemon posset recipe can fail if the ingredients aren’t of high quality. Always use freshly squeezed juice and high-quality cream to keep the texture rich and the flavor vibrant.

Step-by-Step Lemon Posset Recipe for Beginners

Boiling the Cream and Sugar: How to Get the Right Consistency

The beauty of the lemon posset recipe lies in its simplicity, but technique still matters. Begin by combining 2 cups of heavy cream and ¾ cup of granulated sugar in a saucepan over medium heat. Stir constantly to dissolve the sugar. Once combined, bring the mixture to a gentle boil—not a full rolling boil, but one that bubbles lightly. This stage is crucial for reducing the liquid slightly and achieving the rich mouthfeel a classic lemon posset is known for.

Let it simmer for about 3 minutes, stirring frequently. This brief cooking time is just enough to concentrate the flavors and help the mixture set appropriately later on. Remove from the heat and allow it to cool slightly for about 2 minutes before adding the lemon juice.

Adding Lemon Juice: When and How to Do It Properly

For every 2 cups of cream, add about five tablespoons of fresh lemon juice. Stir it in slowly and watch as the mixture thickens almost immediately. This is the natural reaction of the acid curdling the fat in the cream, precisely what makes the lemon posset recipe so unique.

Strain the mixture through a fine mesh sieve for the smoothest texture. Then, pour the liquid evenly into ramekins, cocktail glasses, or jars. This is also your chance to create visual appeal if you’re prepping for a special occasion.

Refrigerate the possets uncovered for at least 4 hours, or overnight for best results. They’ll firm up into a beautifully smooth and creamy dessert.

Chilling Time and Serving Tips

Once set, cover each serving with plastic wrap if you plan to store it for longer than a day. Serve chilled with a twist of lemon zest, a few fresh berries, or even a light shortbread cookie on the side. This lemon posset recipe is best enjoyed within 48 hours, while the flavor is fresh and the texture is at its peak.

Want to explore another bright lemon-based dish? Discover this lemon-chicken-pasta-salad

Expert Tips to Make the Perfect Lemon Posset Every Time

How to Avoid Curdling or Splitting

Even though the lemon posset recipe is straightforward, a few minor missteps can lead to a grainy texture or separation. Here’s how to keep your posset creamy and smooth every time:

• Don’t Overboil the Cream: Heat it just until small bubbles form around the edges. Boiling too hard can cause the fat to break down and the sugar to caramelize, ruining the smooth consistency.
• Cool It Slightly Before Adding Lemon Juice: If the cream is too hot when you add the lemon juice, it may curdle. Let the mixture rest for 1–2 minutes after removing it from the heat, then stir in the citrus.
• Use Fresh Ingredients: Avoid using bottled lemon juice or ultra-pasteurized cream. These can both affect the chemistry and cause your lemon posset to set unevenly.

These expert tricks are what separate an average dessert from a flawless one.

Common Mistakes and How to Fix Them

Everyone makes mistakes when trying a new dessert. The good news is that the most common lemon posset recipe issues are easy to avoid once you know what to look for:

Mistake	Cause	Solution
Posset didn’t set	Not enough lemon juice or cream was too thin	Use full-fat cream and freshly squeezed juice
Grainy or curdled texture	Juice was added while the cream was too hot	Cool the cream for 2 minutes before adding juice
Sour or bitter aftertaste	Overcooked lemon or used old lemons	Use fresh, juicy lemons and strain the juice
Skin forming on top	Possets weren’t covered while chilling	Cover with plastic wrap once fully set

Using these simple techniques ensures your lemon posset recipe sets perfectly with a rich, velvety texture and no curdling. If you’re entertaining, these tips make it easy to prep in advance and wow your guests with zero stress.

How to Make Mary Berry’s Lemon Posset

Mary Berry’s Signature Twist on the Classic Lemon Posset Recipe

No conversation about the lemon posset recipe would be complete without mentioning Mary Berry. Known for her elegant and fuss-free cooking, Mary’s version of this timeless dessert adds a little flair while staying true to its minimalistic roots.

Mary Berry’s lemon posset starts with the same base of double cream and sugar. What makes hers unique is the balance between tang and sweetness. She’s known to use slightly less sugar (about ½ cup) than traditional recipes, allowing the lemon’s brightness to shine through truly. She also emphasizes the use of fine caster sugar, which dissolves more evenly and produces a silkier final texture.

Her method also calls for zesting one of the lemons before juicing it, enhancing the aromatic depth of the lemon posset without altering its smooth consistency.

Step-by-Step Comparison with Traditional Method

Here’s a breakdown comparing Mary Berry’s lemon posset recipe with the more conventional approach:

Step	Traditional Lemon Posset Recipe	Mary Berry’s Lemon Posset
Cream & Sugar Ratio	2 cups cream, ¾ cup sugar	2 cups double cream, ½ cup caster sugar
Lemon Use	5 tbsp fresh juice	5 tbsp juice + zest of 1 lemon
Cooking Duration	Boil 3 minutes	Simmer gently, 2–3 minutes
Texture Outcome	Rich and creamy	Light, silky with aromatic lemon flavor
Ideal Serving Glassware	Any ramekin or glass	Wide champagne flutes or vintage coupes

One of Mary’s pro tips is to strain the posset twice for an ultra-smooth finish, especially useful when zest is used. Her emphasis on presentation also stands out. She often garnishes her lemon posset with fresh raspberries and a sprig of mint, turning a humble dessert into something you’d be proud to serve at any elegant dinner.

If you’ve already mastered the basic lemon posset recipe, give Mary Berry’s style a try for a subtle but noticeable upgrade.

Serving and Garnishing Ideas for Lemon Posset

Toppings That Elevate Your Dessert: Berries, Mint, and Zest

Once your lemon posset recipe has chilled and set, presentation becomes the final touch that transforms it from simple to stunning. Toppings are more than just aesthetic—they add flavor, texture, and contrast.

• Fresh berries, such as raspberries, blueberries, or sliced strawberries, add a burst of color and a hint of tartness that pairs perfectly with the creamy lemon base.
• Mint Leaves: A single mint sprig not only pops visually but brings a fresh, herbal note that enhances the citrusy aroma of the lemon posset.
• Lemon Zest or Candied Peel: Grating a little lemon zest or using candied lemon peel over the top ties the garnish back to the core flavor and creates a gourmet look.

Layering textures can also elevate the dish. Try crushed shortbread or ginger biscuits for a sweet crunch on top of the silky surface. These quick additions can turn your lemon posset recipe into a showstopper for any event.

Elegant Glassware and Presentation Tips for Dinner Parties

How you serve your lemon posset plays a significant role in how it’s perceived. While ramekins work for casual occasions, glass containers are ideal when you’re aiming to impress. Consider:

• Vintage Coupe Glasses: These wide, shallow glasses showcase the posset’s creamy surface and provide a perfect stage for colorful garnishes.
• Mini Mason Jars: Great for portion control and rustic presentation.
• Espresso Cups or Demitasse Glasses: Ideal for tasting menus or bite-sized desserts at cocktail parties.

Presentation tip: Serve your lemon posset recipe chilled on a dessert plate, accompanied by a spoon and a crisp cookie on the side. The contrast between warm pastry and cold posset delights the palate.

Variations of Lemon Posset You Should Try

Orange Posset, Lime Posset, and Other Citrus Alternatives

If you’ve already fallen in love with the traditional lemon posset recipe, it’s time to branch out into other citrus-inspired flavors. The beauty of posset lies in its flexibility—the core structure remains the same, while the flavor can shift depending on the juice you use.

• Orange Posset: Substitute lemon juice with fresh orange juice to create a milder, sweeter dessert. Since oranges are less acidic, you may need to add a bit of lemon juice to help it set.
• Lime Posset: Tart and vibrant, lime makes for a bold, tropical variation. Garnish with coconut flakes or a lime twist for extra flair.
• Grapefruit Posset: Slightly bitter but ultra-refreshing, grapefruit posset is ideal for sophisticated palates. Use ruby red grapefruit for added sweetness and color.

Just like the original lemon posset, these versions are prepared by heating cream and sugar, then stirring in citrus juice. The trick is adjusting the acidity level to ensure proper thickening. A mix of lemon and your chosen fruit juice often strikes the perfect balance.

Dairy-Free or Vegan Options for Lemon Posset Lovers

Want to enjoy a lemon posset recipe but need a dairy-free or vegan alternative? Although the traditional recipe relies on cream, there are a few creative workarounds that mimic its silky texture.

• Coconut Cream Posset: Use full-fat coconut cream and reduce it slightly before adding lemon juice. The natural fat in coconut allows it to set with a pleasantly tropical note.
• Cashew Cream Version: Soaked and blended cashews combined with lemon and a touch of maple syrup can create a nutty, thick base. Set using agar-agar instead of gelatin or natural thickening.
• Oat Cream Alternative: New to the dairy-free market, oat-based cream substitutes are also worth experimenting with, although they may require additional thickening agents.

While the traditional lemon posset recipe is nearly foolproof, these variations offer fresh ways to enjoy the dessert, whether you’re avoiding dairy, trying new flavors, or want a twist on the classic.

Explore another creative dairy-based dessert idea: Check out this lemon-chicken-pasta-salad for tangy flavor combos.

Storing, Freezing, and Making Ahead

How Long Does Lemon Posset Last in the Fridge?

One of the perks of the lemon posset recipe is how well it stores. Once set, the lemon posset can be refrigerated for up to 3 days without losing flavor or texture. Just make sure it’s covered tightly with plastic wrap or stored in a container with a lid to avoid absorbing fridge odors.

For best results, chill the posset uncovered for the first 4–6 hours to allow it to set correctly, then cover it when storing overnight or for longer. If you’re serving this dessert for guests, you can easily prepare it the day before and focus on garnishes and plating the next day.

Can You Freeze Lemon Posset Without Ruining the Texture?

While not commonly done, you can freeze lemon posset. However, be aware that the texture may change slightly when thawed. The cream can separate a bit, which may make the surface look uneven or less smooth. That said, if you’re freezing leftovers or planning to enjoy it yourself, this might not be an issue.

Here are a few freezing tips for your lemon posset recipe:

• Freeze in individual portions using freezer-safe containers with lids.
• Let the posset thaw overnight in the fridge—don’t microwave or leave it at room temperature.
• Stir lightly after thawing to restore creaminess, if needed.

For best quality, consume frozen posset within 2 weeks. Beyond that, texture loss becomes more noticeable.

Hosting a dinner party? Lemon posset makes for the perfect prep-ahead dessert—cool, creamy, and elegant.

Looking for another crowd-pleasing option? Try our citrus-packed lemon-chicken-pasta-salad

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Conclusion

The beauty of a lemon posset recipe lies in its simplicity. With just cream, sugar, and lemon juice, you can create a decadent, velvety dessert that feels fancy yet requires no baking or complicated steps. Whether you’re making the classic version, Mary Berry’s twist, or experimenting with citrus variations, the lemon posset is a perfect make-ahead treat that never fails to impress.

From proper ingredient selection and technique tips to garnish ideas and vegan alternatives, this guide has covered everything you need to master the art of lemon posset. So why not try it tonight and see just how effortless elegance can be?

Print